At a Glance: Top 5 Lubbock Roofers Compared
Ratings and certifications were verified as of May 2026. Review counts change over time, so always check current ratings on Google Business Profile and BBB before hiring.
| Rank | Company | Founded | Top Certification | BBB | Reviews |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Hartman Roofing | 1988 | GAF Master Elite (top 2-3% nationwide) | A+, no complaints | 4.8★ (127+ Google) |
| 2 | Kincaid Roofing & Remodeling | 2005 | Owens Corning Platinum Preferred (only one within 100 mi) | A+, no complaints | 4.9★ (236+ across platforms) |
| 3 | Andrus Brothers Roofing | 1981 | BBB Accredited, Best of Lubbock recipient | Accredited | Multi-year Best of Lubbock |
| 4 | Plains Roofing | 1939 | 30+ years A+ BBB | A+ | 40,000+ projects completed |
| 5 | Forster Construction | 1985 | GAF Master Elite plus 10 other manufacturer certifications | A+, Accredited | Multi-region (TX + NM) |
1. Hartman Roofing
Hartman Roofing earned the top spot because it holds the strongest single certification available to a residential roofer: GAF Master Elite. That distinction is awarded to fewer than 3% of roofing contractors in the country, and it requires sustained training, verified install volume, and customer satisfaction tracking. In Lubbock specifically, Hartman has held the certification for years while maintaining an A+ Better Business Bureau rating with zero filed complaints. The family-owned operation has been working in Lubbock since 1988 and serves the surrounding region from Plainview down to Brownfield and east to Crosbyton. Reviewers consistently mention three things: clean job sites, reliable communication during the install, and crews that show up when scheduled. The Google review average sits at 4.8 stars across more than 120 reviews. The materials lineup includes GAF, Malarkey, and CertainTeed, and the GAF Master Elite tier qualifies for longer manufacturer-backed warranties than non-certified competitors can offer.
- Founded
- 1988 (37 years in Lubbock)
- Top Certification
- GAF Master Elite Residential Contractor
- BBB
- A+ Accredited, no complaints filed
- Reviews
- 4.8★ on Google (127+ reviews)
- Address
- 2108 109th Street, Lubbock, TX 79423
- Phone
- (806) 615-0061
- Service area
- Lubbock, Plainview, Littlefield, Levelland, Brownfield, Slaton, Post, New Home, Crosbyton, Floydada
2. Kincaid Roofing & Remodeling
Kincaid Roofing & Remodeling holds the strongest distinction of any roofer in the Lubbock area: it is the only Owens Corning Platinum Preferred Contractor within 100 miles. Platinum is the top tier in the Owens Corning network and the certification gates access to manufacturer warranties unavailable through standard contractors. Kincaid pairs that with the highest aggregate review count we found in the Lubbock roofing market: 236 reviews across Birdeye with a 4.9-star average, plus 219 Google reviews and a perfect 5-star Angi rating across 55 reviews. Founded in 2005, Kincaid does residential and commercial roofing along with windows and siding. The company emphasizes hand-nailed installations on every job, which exceeds the speed-pneumatic-nailer standard most competitors use and produces a measurably better long-term hold. The workmanship warranty is five years on residential roofs with one year of interior leak damage coverage, and commercial NDL warranties run 10 to 20 years through Johns Manville. Customer reviews highlight multi-decade loyalty, with one Lubbock client noting they had used Kincaid for 18 consecutive years.
- Founded
- 2005 (20 years in Lubbock)
- Top Certification
- Owens Corning Platinum Preferred Contractor (only one within 100 miles)
- Other credentials
- RCAT License #03-0268, Johns Manville NDL, RCAT member, Lubbock Area Roofing Contractors Association, West Texas Home Builders Association
- BBB
- A+ Accredited, no complaints filed
- Reviews
- 4.9★ Google (219), 4.9★ Birdeye (236), 5.0★ Angi (55)
- Warranty
- 5-year workmanship + 1-year interior leak damage
- Address
- 5701 122nd Street, Lubbock, TX 79424
- Phone
- (806) 788-1460
3. Andrus Brothers Roofing
Andrus Brothers has been roofing West Texas longer than almost anyone else still operating. The company was founded in 1981 in Amarillo, opened its Lubbock office in 1989, and added Midland in 2005. That 44-year track record gets reinforced by repeat Best of Lubbock recognition and Choice Awards in 2023, 2024, and 2025. The family-owned operation handles composition shingles, impact-resistant shingles, designer shingles, metal roofs, wood shakes, tile, and what the company calls Luxury Roofscapes for higher-end residential builds. Andrus is BBB-accredited and works with the major roofing manufacturers, though it does not publicly advertise specific certification tiers the way Hartman and Kincaid do. The company carries significant brand authority in the Lubbock market. When local homeowners ask for recommendations, Andrus is consistently among the first names mentioned. Its three-office footprint means the same operation can service homes across the South Plains, Permian Basin, and Eastern New Mexico, which is rare for a roofer in this market.
- Founded
- 1981 (44 years; 36 years in Lubbock specifically)
- Founders
- Jerry and Steve Andrus
- Offices
- Amarillo (HQ), Lubbock (1989), Midland (2005), Eastern New Mexico
- BBB
- Accredited
- Awards
- Best of Lubbock (multi-year), Choice Awards 2023-2025, HomeAdvisor certified
- Services
- Composition, impact-resistant, designer shingles, metal, wood shakes, tile, Luxury Roofscapes, commercial
- Address
- 210 CR 7200, Lubbock, TX 79404
- Phone
- (806) 798-7663
4. Plains Roofing
Plains Roofing is the oldest roofing company still operating in Lubbock. Founded in 1939, the company has been at the same A+ Better Business Bureau rating for over 30 years and reports 40,000+ completed projects across its 86-year history. That kind of institutional tenure is genuinely rare in residential construction. Most American roofing companies do not survive past a single generation, and Plains has now operated through four. The company handles residential and commercial roofing, real estate inspections, maintenance, and hail damage work, with the bulk of its current business in the Lubbock metro. Plains Roofing does not publicly advertise specific manufacturer certification tiers on its website, which is the main reason it ranks fourth rather than higher. For homeowners specifically shopping by manufacturer warranty (Owens Corning Platinum, GAF Master Elite, etc.), Kincaid or Hartman are stronger picks. But for homeowners who weight institutional history and a long, complaint-free BBB record above newer certification programs, Plains has more credibility than any other roofer on this list.
- Founded
- 1939 (86 years; oldest roofer in Lubbock)
- BBB
- A+ rating maintained for 30+ years
- Project history
- 40,000+ completed projects
- Services
- Residential and commercial roofing, real estate inspections, maintenance, hail damage repair
- Address
- 5710 Avenue Q, Lubbock, TX 79412
- Phone
- (806) 748-0702
5. Forster Construction
Forster Construction is the broadest commercial roofer on this list. Founded by Glenn Forster in 1985, the company holds the most diverse certification portfolio we found in the Lubbock market: GAF Master Elite alongside Duro-Last, Johns Manville, Malarkey, CertainTeed, Owens Corning, Mule-Hide, Alucobond, McElroy Metal, MCA Clay Roof Tile, and Berridge. That breadth makes Forster particularly well-suited for commercial buildings, multi-tenant residential, and any project that benefits from being able to specify a specific manufacturer's system without sourcing through a third party. The company is licensed and bonded in both Texas and New Mexico and runs jobs across a 13-city service area from Abilene to Clovis NM. Forster maintains A+ BBB accreditation and operates as a family-owned business, with a service mix that leans more commercial than the other companies on this list. Homeowners with standard single-family residential roofs may find Hartman, Kincaid, or Andrus a better fit for the typical asphalt shingle replacement. But for anyone managing a flat roof, large commercial building, multi-family property, or unusual specification, Forster's certification breadth becomes a real advantage.
- Founded
- 1985 (40 years)
- Owner
- Glenn Forster
- Licensed
- Texas and New Mexico
- Certifications
- GAF Master Elite, Duro-Last, Johns Manville, Malarkey, CertainTeed, Owens Corning, Mule-Hide, Alucobond, McElroy Metal, MCA Clay Roof Tile, Berridge
- BBB
- A+ Accredited
- Service area
- Lubbock, Abilene, Amarillo, Big Spring, Brownfield, Clovis NM, Hobbs NM, Lovington, Midland, Odessa, Plainview, San Angelo, Sweetwater
- Address
- 8602 Ash Avenue D1, Lubbock, TX 79404
- Phone
- (806) 794-5600
Honorable Mentions
Several other Lubbock-area roofers did not make the top five but are worth mentioning for specific use cases. Maverick Roofing LLC was founded by owner-operator Bret Addlesberger and emphasizes that the owner is present on every job and that no work is subcontracted. The company has 20+ years of combined team experience and uses GAF shingles and Carlisle rubber. Massie Roofing LLC carries A+ BBB accreditation, is bonded and insured, and has built a reputation as a reliable mid-size operation handling residential and commercial roofing along with soffit, siding, skylights, gutters, and foam insulation. Roof-Tech is a smaller family-operated outfit that runs seven days a week and earns consistently strong online reviews. Its public web presence is limited, which is the main reason it does not break into the top five despite the positive sentiment. American Roofing Lubbock TX has the strongest organic search visibility of any small Lubbock roofer, which makes it easy to find online. Edge Roofing & Coatings is veteran-owned, was founded in 2006, and carries an A+ BBB rating with a specialization in roof coatings alongside traditional roofing services.
What to Look For in a Lubbock Roofer
Lubbock's combination of summer hail, dust storms, intense UV index, and extreme temperature swings puts unusual stress on residential roofs. Five things matter more here than in most Texas markets.
- Manufacturer certification tier. GAF Master Elite (top 2-3% nationally) and Owens Corning Platinum Preferred qualify for longer manufacturer warranties and confirm the roofer has been independently audited on training, install volume, and customer outcomes.
- BBB rating with no filed complaints. An A+ BBB rating means the company has responded to inquiries and resolved any disputes. A zero-complaint history is a stronger signal than the rating alone. Always check the BBB profile, not just the website's claimed rating.
- Years operating in the Lubbock market specifically. A roofer with 20+ years of South Plains experience has weathered the hail seasons that define our market. Newer operations may be excellent but lack the storm-response track record.
- Workmanship warranty terms. Manufacturer warranties cover material defects. Workmanship warranties cover installation. The strongest Lubbock roofers offer 5-year workmanship coverage at minimum, and the best (Kincaid) also cover interior damage from leaks for the first year.
- In-writing quotes with line-item detail. The clearest signal of a trustworthy contractor is a written quote that itemizes materials, labor, tear-off, dump fees, and warranty terms separately. Verbal-only quotes are a red flag. One of the few negative review themes we found across all top companies involved a roofer reluctant to commit to a written estimate.
A Note from the Publisher
This article was researched and published by Nextgen Blueprint, a Lubbock-based general contractor. Roofing is one service we offer as part of full-service home remodeling, but we excluded ourselves from this comparison to keep it editorially neutral. If you want to know how we approach roofing (Class 4 impact-rated systems for hail country, post-storm inspections, and full restoration of any drywall or interior damage caused by roof issues), see our Roofing service page linked below. Otherwise, the five companies above are the strongest independent options in the Lubbock market as of May 2026. Ratings, certifications, and review counts cited in this article were verified at the time of publication. These details change over time, so we update this article quarterly. Always check current Google reviews and BBB profiles before hiring any contractor.